Originally Posted by
JonnyVain
I agree with what you're saying if you're talking about new models of the same bike, but my reach did increase by about 2" going from one bike to the next. For example, the reach is 55mm different between a large Rockhopper and a large Chameleon.
I also shortened the stem on the Hardrock from 80mm to 60mm, not for reach but for geometry.
I really don't understand your first sentence at all.
If your question/observation about new vs older bikes, I can't really follow any of what you are saying without model years attached to all the bikes you are talking about.
Also, when you say "my reach" are you talking about the reach measurement of the frame or the saddle to grips reach or your cockpit setup?
Keep in mind that some bikes models (especially from different companies) size there bikes differently. Additionally, some models are intended to be run with shorter or longer stems than others.