View Single Post
Old 05-12-18 | 05:09 PM
  #21  
Sy Reene's Avatar
Sy Reene
Advocatus Diaboli
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: Feb 2015
Posts: 9,143
Likes: 1,736
From: Wherever I am

Bikes: Merlin Cyrene, Nashbar steel CX

Originally Posted by CliffordK
I think there is a continuous wear caused by stretching a chain.

So, it isn't that everything is just fine up until 0.5%, or 0.8%, then all hell breaks loose.

Rather, a new cassette should work best with 0% chain wear, and will start seeing the chain climbing on the sprockets as one starts getting chain wear, and thus damaging the cassette.

So, extending that period of time just makes sense to me.

The question then is whether one is better off say rotating chains.

Riding to say 0.1% wear. Pulling it, putting a new chain on, riding it to 0.1% wear, then putting the original back on and riding it to 0.2% wear before rotating again.

That would be a lot of rotating, but a good opportunity for cleaning and maintenance.

And, of course, I hate putting a partly worn chain back onto my good cassettes and chainrings.

I do distribute my riding between a couple of bikes, but I do get quite a few miles in a year, so I can chew through quite a few chains & etc.

What I'll probably do is keep good chains on the road bike, then rotate them onto the commuter. Perhaps I can even break the sprockets into say a 0.3% worn chain.

As far as chain value:

Say Chain X costs $25
And Chain Y costs $50, but gets 2x the wear of chain X. Then I believe Chain Y may be a better deal due to making the chain wear through the least damaging periods longer. If, however, Chain Y gets 3x the wear, then it should be the obvious choice.

As stated, I'm still early in the Wippermann testing, but I have high hopes.
You seemingly have seen the Wipperman test charts (which I've posted as well in other recent threads)? I'm not sure what your theory is as regards to what the least damaging period is(?), but the SX chain according to their chart, lasted 85 hours to get to .5% wear (great, right?). However, 60 of the 85 hours (70%) were spent in the .3 to .5% region. Isn't this then the chain that will be used in its most damaging period (to your cassette, chainrings) for the largest proportion of its lifetime?
Sy Reene is offline  
Reply