Thanks for the answers. Umh they are both unconfortable for my butt 😆
the new one make a bit of noise when the spring compress but most of the uncomfortable fact are to the large size. As a roadie i prefer those opened saddle very narrow.

what about the eastetics?
do you prefer the cheap leather clone or this one i posted?
I can't decide because one is real vintage but ugly and the other one is not vintage but looks new.