I tried out the Fabric Scoop flat on a 50 mile ride. It is not as flat as my Ergon SMC4, it has little more slope on the side that initially felt comfortable. It also has less cushioning than the Ergon. By the end of the ride I was feeling sore and numb. It's a nice looking saddle, and I thought about keeping it for shorter rides on another bike, but still feeling sore a day later and decided to return it. I'll keep experimenting to see if I can find the perfect saddle.