Originally Posted by
Wattsup
The OP implies by one of his comments that he enjoys the relaxed geometry of his Vaya, and is appreciative that the Cutthroat shares similar geometry. The Cutthroat in fact is a bit more relaxed than the Vaya, more along the lines of the Fargo. The Revolt on the other hand is less relaxed, lower stack and higher reach, and might not meet the OP's needs. The Giant Anyroad however has very similar geometry to his Vaya, but the stock wheels are boat anchors, (I know, I own an Anyroad CoMax,.). Even with those 2200g boat anchors, my large Anyroad weighs only 22.2 lbs, less than the Cutthroat Apex large's 23.25 lbs, and that's with two rings up front, vs the Salsa's one. As a another poster pointed out earlier, the Cutthroat does take up to 3" tires. My Anyroad will just fit 42mm.
he also said replacing his road bike with a Defy. and the 2019 Revolt would have a much larger head tube than the defy and also fit a 700x45 tire.

for a nice all rounder bicycle
I've been thinking about replacing my carbon road bike which is a little small. Thought I might look to replace it with something like the Giant Defy 2 but not sure I want to sink a lot of money into a road bike. I ride 40-100 miles a week, enjoy all types of surface. Not sure the Cutthroat is an all-arounder...