It took 5 different saddles before I found one that was comfortable to me. Some would feel good initially, but after 30 min., it was very uncomfortable. The LBS that I bought my bike from allowed me to exchange saddles. After going through 4 saddles with them, I felt I wanted to try a different approach and other brands. A different LBS had loaner saddles to try and the first loaner I tried was the one for me. I had done a professional bike fit shortly after buying my bike, so the fit wasn’t the issue. There are lots of nuances in saddle shape so I believe you just have to try them. I envy those people that can ride most any saddle because I can’t. Many of the most popular saddles just didn’t work for me.

Mark