I have been commuting and other riding in the rain with the same Nashbar cycling rain jacket/shell for at least 12 years. It has served me well, but it isn't breathable, and after 15 minutes of riding gets muggy and sticky inside and somehow I always still end up being wet underneath with a mixture of sweat and rain.
Its time for something new and better. I need something suitable for commuting in wet cool weather that will keep me warm and comfortable (if not totally dry). Would like it to be fairly stuffable as well, and easily pack it in a pocket or small bag when its not raining.

I haven't paid much attention to rain gear on a loooong time and I am sure there have been many improvements in what is available..anyone have any good suggestions?