Originally Posted by
3speed
Large panniers seem like they would be overkill for CC touring. I would think something small and light like the Arkel dry light would be preferable. Light weight, completely waterproof, and not as much wind resistance as comes with larger bags. Some of those and a rando front rack top bag(for quick access things, snacks, valuables) seem like a great pair for CC touring.
Agree on the large bags. I replaced my Ortleib Backrollers with Ortleib Frontrollers. Even for camping-tours. Just did a CC trip down part of the Katy, and my gear was in a handlebar roll, with a soft-sided cooler strapped to the rear rack. Fortunately my bike has all kinds of gear storage options including a frame bag and fork cages, but that stuff usually doesn't get used unless there's camping involved. For credit card touring, small panniers or a handlebar roll seems to do the trick. Maybe both if the weather might turn cold because cold weather gear takes up more space.