Originally Posted by
Giant40
tightening it as much as I could
Sounds like over tightening. Just snug it up a bit past where it stops turning, that's all. Don't over tighten.
Sometimes they clog with sealant. The spit test or soapy water will reveal bubbles if it is leaking.
Valve cores are $10/dozen online. I just replace when they start to get clogged up.
-Tim-