Originally Posted by
Kapusta
You probably did not get more responses because you did not give enough info.
What kind of riding do you do? More XC/racing focus or want something a bit slacker and more all around playful? You like to plow through the rough stuff or pick your way through it? Do you like to drop off of stuff?
At your weight, your own level of finesse and smoothness will make a big difference in terms of trashing wheels and drivetrains.
For a $1500 budget, and starting from (I assume) scratch, I think you doing the right thing looking for a complete bike.
Are you dead set on Al, or is steel an option?
I would say I'm looking for something a bit slacker, I like to climb hills, go fast, but mostly trail riding with some paved/chip seal/gravel roads as well. I also used my previous mtb to commute to work with an urban assault mentality a few times a week.
I am leaning towards aluminum because even though I'm a big guy, I can appreciate the feel of a lightweight bike beneath me. Carbon just gives me pause, I'd hate to just fall over on the bike and need a frame. Haven't seen any steel options out there but to be honest I haven't looked.
I'm open to suggestions, I also find myself looking at a few full suspension bikes that fit into my price range.