So I am trying to figure out how to build up a new bike. Unfortunately mine was recently stolen, and I am thinking about the right upgrades. I previously had an Alfine 8, and I want more range for my next bike. I am a mostly urban cyclist but live in a hilly neighborhood. Also plan to do some short gran fondos in the future.
So these are my 3 options. In addition to adding more range, I value aesthetics, and I like classic 40s vintage style bikes. So whatever I end up with, it'll will look vintage and classic constructeur and randonneuring looking bikes.
Pinion pros and cons:- pro: moves the weight from the rear to center, huge gear range
- cons: doesn't look very classic, locks you into limited frame options
Alfine 11 pros and cons:- pro: it is similar to my old hub and I know how it works, lightest option
- cons: ugly shifter, limited after-market options
Nuvinci pros and cons:- pro: unlimited gearing, I've found an attractive after-market shifter option, better belt drive compatibility
- cons: haven't used it, not sure how it shifts under load
So, anyone have any experience with these hubs - which direction would you go?