Originally Posted by 55/Rad
Going from 18 to 15.5 can feel semi-substantlal, particularly if the loss is in the area of rotational weight - wheels, tires, cranks, pedals etc. The biggest gain is in pure acceleration, particulary from a stop or a very low speed.
That said, it won't necessarily make you "faster" overall. I'd rather be cruising on an 18 pounder at 20-25 mph than on a 15. I'd also prefer the heavier bike on descents. But I'd rather have the 15 on a hillclimb, starting from a light or coming out of a turn.
The key is to finding a good balance. 18 is not heavy by any means and for me, is in the range being ideal.
55/Rad
Im fond of this post. I agree about a happy medium. When I was in vermont on a tour, there was some heavy hill climbing when we were forced to take our penniers and all the stuff we were carrying on our bike, a good 20-30 pounds we were acustomed to. It was wierd, but a good wierd, especially when were doin 10%-12% climbing. But, I have to say, it was hell the next day when we put it all back on.