Originally Posted by
Doug64
David, did you need a shorter bottom bracket when you put the mtn crank on the Troll? OP, you can check your present chainline on the Troll by measuring from the center of the seat tube to the center of the middle chainring. If it is in the 45 mm range, you may need a shorter bottom bracket. If it is around 50 mm, you might be OK.
If you presently have a 5-arm crank, I'm not sure there are any 22 tooth chainrings that will fit it. Usually you have to go to a 4-arm mtn crank.
Hi Doug, when I bought my troll used, it had the mtb crank on it, and I did remember your explanation from years past about the chainline--but this was my first bike not using square taper bb, it has the hollowtech external bb, and apparently to do a change from a 48/36/26 Deore to a 44/32/22 Deore using that type of external bb that doesnt have an axle running through the bb, apparently its an easy swap.
A friend of mine with a Troll did the change, from the stock 48/36/26 to a mtb one when he did about half of The Divide Ride trail, and while he had it done at a store, I seem to recall that it was straightforward according to him, although its very possible that some spacers were positioned differently for the mtb crank.
I know when I stripped my Troll down to the frame to give it a complete do over before my first big trip with it (put some Framesaver inside it at the same time) this was my first time disassembling and then putting back together a hollowtech bb, and it was rather straightforward. I had to buy a new bb tool with the right splines for the shells, but it went well overall and I didnt screw anything up.
I have a feeling that the 48/36/26 and the mtb cranks in hollowtech have very similar "chainlines", but I could be wrong.
The fellow on here named Gauvins has changed his 48/36/26 granny to a 22, so it certainly is doable. I may change my wifes 26 to a smaller one one day, but so far, with the 10 speed 11-36 on it combined with the 26inch wheels, the gearing is pretty darn good as is.
we are just about to get some double digit temp days here, nice change.
cheers