I've not ridden a lot of the more expensive saddles, Selle Anatomica, Brooks, etc, but I have ridden lots of saddles. The one I've found most comfortable so far, and would not hesitate to buy again, and is cheap in comparison to many, is Serfas' Dorado: https://www.serfas.com/shop/products...rado-chromoly/ Now, I'm not heavy (around 155 lbs.) and don't like narrow, skinny saddles. I do like support and this one provides it, without being a brick. BTW-Serfas states they have a 90 day comfort guarantee-it's on their site.