I wouldn't ask us. It's your feet. Try them both on. My feet love the lasts of Lake shoes. I have a bunch of them. (I run three different cleat systems and like having both laced and strap/buckle pairs.) I periodically go out and try on fancier shoes but I rarely find a fit my feet actually like except on those Lakes that are too inexpensive to be called "good shoes" (though they are well made and last me a long time). I have a couple of pairs of really good, light shoes but I rarely wear them and it is always "let me have those Lakes" when I do.

Edit: 130 miles riding fixed is no big deal for my feet in those Lakes.