Originally Posted by
WizardOfBoz
I'm assuming that Loose Chain also holds an A&P* rating if he's TIG welding on airframes. I'd tend to give creed to what he says.
The strength of a frame with a repair weld will be less than that of a properly welded and heat-treated frame , unless you heat treat the repair welded frame afterwards. If you do HT the repaired frame you're going to have to repaint.
Lowering the seat of a bike significantly reduces your mechanical and physiological efficiency.
As others have pointed out, a longer seat post reinforces the seat tube to a point, but if your long seat post extends a long way, you still have a larger moment arm. Probably good to think about a larger frame if you can.
*Airframe and Powerplant mechanics rating, needed to work on commercial aircraft.
I think you may have sightly misunderstood, yes, I am an A&P, IA, but I have my little TIG unit for home hobby use. I use an oxy-acetylene torch for for welded steel tube (4130) repairs. I can control the heat much better including slowly withdrawing the torch flame. TIG, at least at the level of machine I have I do not have that sort of control.