Originally Posted by
robow
I owned two Selle Anatomica saddles, both had the "thickest" treated leather they offered which were supposed to stretch the least. They were both very comfortable but both stretched out and showed significant sag quite quickly, such that I went back to my Brooks. I weighed probably about 170-175 lbs at that time. YMMV
Looks like SA's leather supplier really lacked the expertise to tan those hides for intended application. SA ought to replace those saddles free under warranty.