View Single Post
Old 04-24-20 | 07:59 AM
  #33  
cyccommute's Avatar
cyccommute
Mad bike riding scientist
Titanium Club Membership
20 Anniversary
Community Builder
Community Influencer
 
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 29,211
Likes: 6,286
From: Denver, CO

Bikes: Some silver ones, a red one, a black and orange one, and a few titanium ones

Originally Posted by Kimmo
Um, that's exactly what I'm saying. Those two bearings' outer races, how are they part of the hub? They're not. They're part of the cassette body, which is separate from the hub. They don't hold the wheel up at all. They have exactly the same job as the corresponding bearings in a Shimano hub. Which you'd know are adjustable via shims, if you'd ever disassembled a Shimano cassette body. I believe there may be a link in my tag.
Cartridge bearing hubs run the axle through the bearings of the freehub body making them weight bearing. Look at the picture again. See how the bearing on the left side of the hub has the axle running through it? And, I suspect that you’ll accept the axle running through the bearing in the left side of the hub shell. The axle also runs through the bearings of the freehub in exactly the same way. Because the axle runs through those bearings, they are also weight bearing. The freehub shell rotates on the those bearings but that doesn’t mean that the bearings aren’t also rotating on the hub axle nor that they aren’t bearing weight.

The Shimano freehub body bolts to the hub shell. The inner part of the freehub body turns with the hub while the outer part turns on its own very, very, very small bearings. A picture of a disassembled freehub body can be found here. Those bearings don’t carry weight. Because the freehub body isn’t in contact with the axle except where the bearings fo the hub contact it at the end.

I see what you were getting at with the shims now but your post was very confusing. You seemed to talking about hubs and not the freehub body. As for taking one apart, I don’t. I treat them like I do freewheels. Servicing one just isn’t worth the effort. They are fairly easily removed and replaced.

Originally Posted by Kimmo
Nope nope-itty nope. That's precisely backwards.
No, it is not backwards. Think of it this way. The axle is just a tube. Support the tube on both ends and put weight on it. The center is going to deflect downward because it is surrounded by open space. Now take that same tube and put additional support in the middle and put weight on it. The center won’t defect downward as much. The more support, the less it deflects. Add to that the fact that the axle on the Phill Wood (and most every other cartridge bearing hub) has a wider diameter and you have a stronger axle that is supported better.

Originally Posted by Kimmo
Some brands of hub acknowledge this shortcoming by using a larger drive side axle bearing, or a pair of bearings. Still crap.
That your opinion and it is still wrong.
__________________
Stuart Black
Dreamin' of Bemidji Down the Mississippi (in part)
Plan Epsilon Around Lake Michigan in the era of Covid
Gold Fever Three days of dirt in Colorado
Pokin' around the Poconos A cold ride around Lake Erie
Dinosaurs in Colorado A mountain bike guide to the Purgatory Canyon dinosaur trackway
Solo Without Pie. The search for pie in the Midwest.
Picking the Scablands. Washington and Oregon, 2005. Pie and spiders on the Columbia River!





cyccommute is offline  
Reply