View Single Post
Old 05-03-20 | 01:30 AM
  #15  
canklecat's Avatar
canklecat
Me duelen las nalgas
10 Anniversary
 
Joined: Aug 2015
Posts: 13,519
Likes: 2,832
From: Texas

Bikes: Centurion Ironman, Trek 5900, Univega Via Carisma, Globe Carmel

I'm always piddling around with gear changes just to see what seems to work for me.

One problem I've found with the contemporary compact setup -- 50/34 or something similar, with 11 or 12 tooth small cog to compensate -- is that at least with my bikes and gear, I can feel some odd vibration and resistance. Some tech-minded folks attribute this to chordal action. Apparently combining some chains with tighter wraps around smaller cogs/gears causes inefficiencies that don't appear on charts.

On my older road bikes (all 7-speed, usual dual 130 BCD chainring) the smallest chainring to fit was 38T. With the 50T big ring I had to try several freewheels to find one that didn't grind in the 13T smallest rear cog. Finally, last year, I gave up on the 50T chainrings and switched back to 52. That way I can use the 14 or 15 rear cogs without that odd grinding/resistance. It's still there when I'm in the 52/13 combo, but that's only on downhills. I can't hold a 52/13 combo on flat terrain for any time unless there's a tailwind.

For the past year I've mostly ridden bikes with 52/42 Biopace chainrings and 13-28 freewheels and cassettes. A week or so ago I switched my Ironman back to 52/39 round rings (same 13-28 SunRace freewheel). So far that's been good enough for our climbs, even into headwinds. I'm a very middling climber and would take any advantage I could get. But I haven't really needed easier gears ... yet. Subject to change with age. A few years ago I was satisfied with a 42 small chainring and 24 largest rear cog. I wouldn't be happy with that now.

I'm about to build up a newer frame, a mid-2000s carbon fiber frame from a friend, as a 10 or 11 speed. It'll be interesting to see whether a new, high quality 11-32 or comparable cassette also has that grinding chordal action in the smallest cog -- although I doubt I'll use it very often anyway.

Anyway, I can understand why the pro teams are finessing lots of little things in pursuit of small advantages, including oversized pulleys.
canklecat is offline  
Reply