Originally Posted by
jep0726
Hey Everyone.
I currently have a Trek 7.2 fx in 17.5 frame, It's ancient now and has had a good life but it's time for a new one.
I'm looking to replace it, I ride both groomed trails and paved roads. This will probably be my last bike purchase given the time in my life.
My rides are anywhere between 20-85km.
Since COVID 19 I do not have many options, I'm unable to shop in the store and it's been so long since I've bought a new bike.
My options are:
Trek Marlin 6
Giant Roam 2 or 3
Liv Rove 2 & 4
Is there one that stands out as a Do Not Buy. I'd like to eliminate what I can.
Also, I realize I may have to change the rubber on some of these.
PLEASE HELP
Honestly, I am also wondering why you would want to switch from the 7.2 FX. Just replace parts as they wear and you should be good. I am thinking none of the bikes you listed are all that much better than your old bike. Just a thought.
You didn't mention the year you bought the Trek, but the older FX 7.2s were actually pretty nice bikes, and had an aluminum frame with steel fork, and 3 x 8 drivetrain. It seems to me the Giant Roam 2 and 3 aren't that much better. I can't tell by the specs, but the drive train is either 3 x 8 or 3 x 9. I suppose the disc brakes are an upgrade, but IMO, not enough by itself to upgrade. If I were looking to upgrade, I would think 1 x 11 or 2 x 11 would be a clear upgrade over 3 x 8.