Another option in the Conti line is the GP 4 Season almost as much puncture protection as the Gatorskins but with a better ride feel, 2200 miles and 2 punctures.
Originally Posted by
WhyFi
Gatorskins do not have the best reputation unless puncture resistance is far and away the highest priority. Staying within the Conti line-up, the GP5000 are seen as an excellent all-arounder. That said, I don't have experience with either because I'm running tubeless.
My tire of choice, Schwalbe Pro One Addix TLE is pretty fantastic - supple feel, great grip, seem to roll very easily, and more than adequate in terms of wear/mileage - and they do make a tube-type version; assuming that it's similar to the TLE, it would be worth checking out.