Originally Posted by
Cycletography
I do not have a power meter on the Ogre, but my new road bike will have a power meter. The new power meter and my desire to make measurable improvements in 2021 is what's prompting my consideration of TP. To date I've primarily used heart data to drive my zone training, and it's worked vwry well, but that method has limitations. The power meter opens up new options for more targeted and reliable zone training.
I'll just drop the hot take and my 2 cents and take my lumps... Training by HR is unreliable and at best gives only a moderate chance of improvement. Too many variables go into your HR that are not the work you are performing (illness, dehydration, heat, cold, hangover, emotional state...), whereas a PM measures ONLY your actual power output and doesn't care what your HR is or what your PE is. A watt is a watt, whether you felt strong or you felt like you were pedaling through wet cement.
I'm 47 years old, and I am fitter than I ever was back when I raced crits in the late 80s/early 90s, for a variety of reasons, including that I now ride year around, where I most definitely did not do that growing up in western Michigan. The reason why I am fitter, IMHO, was adding a PM to my road bike in 2016, and by 2017 I had one on my gravel rig and 2018 on my MTB. Every ride (commutes too) is a training opportunity. Wait, you say, doesn't that take all the enjoyment out of it? Not at all, I now ride with purpose, while I still get to "learn the contours of the land," and now I actually get to be faster even if "it never gets easier" (except for the recovery rides). I always ride with a PM so that I don't over-train, and I can also evaluate if I undershot my targets. My training program is structured so that I do shorter interval work during the week (maximizing my commutes one way, with a short recovery ride the other), and longer endurance focused rides on the weekends. I still do junk miles with my kids to the local MTB tracks, and I give myself "free days" to go crush gravel. I get to do all the rides I want, but they all have meaning and purpose toward my bigger goals.
Okay so TP premium...don't do a trial until you have the PM and you've ridden with it for a while. It will waste the two weeks. When you first get a PM you're going to see your power go all over the place, it'll be confusing, it won't make sense...for a few weeks, then it will start to make sense as you get a better feel for what different power numbers feel like, and you also get smoother on the crank. If you don't have one, you may want to consider a Garmin Edge that has FirstBeat metrics incorporated to the software (Edge 530, 820 Plus, 1030/1030 Plus). With those devices, and the settings arranged so, a ride of sufficient duration will return estimated FTP and VO2Max values, they can also be used to perform a structured FTP test and return a more accurate value also. A smoother pedal stroke, and some sense of your actual power thresholds will then allow you to get the most out of a balanced, structured training program with the goals you desire, and the analytics in TrainingPeaks will allow you maximize your efforts. Having a coach is helpful, but not required, there are several great books that you can get to help you understand the physiological
Apologies for the length. Bottomline: TrainingPeaks can be a great tool, with a little forethought and preparation, you can really get a lot out of it, in my opinion. I also am not an expert or a coach, but I've been training with power for over 4 years now, so I have some layman's experience.