Good LBS. If the current saddle still causes problems, ask if they have any loaners to try. I was in your same boat, and with my LBS and REI letting me try various saddles I was able to find one that worked. I tried a Selle Anatomica and found that did not really work the best and the worry of not getting it wet was a concern. I want a saddle I can just use and not have to make sure I cover it in the rain or when on the back of my car rack.