I think it is safe to say that a wider tire is more comfortable than a narrower tire.

As far as being faster, I think there are other variables that impact speed more than just tire width.

Personally, for a lot on non-competitive riders, I think dollars spent per mile probably has a greater influence on tire selection than getting the fastest tire available.

I should add that flats per ride might have a greater influence than the optimum rolling resistance. Fixing a flat turns the fastest tire into the slowest.

Everything is a compromise.

John