Conclusion
Care for a lightweight pedal but hoping for something a bit more stable and durable? Stable they are, durable they may be. Three of our four test pedals had seals pop out on the second ride, and the bearing feel never improved. We'd love to endorse them, but there's some kind of unresolved quality issue with these pedals. Seals literally popped out on the first ride. Would be 5 star without this issue. Please get it together Shimano, I really wanted to love these.
— Joshua Hutchens