Originally Posted by
Russ Roth
I don't like the big jumps of the larger cassettes. Both my gravel and cross bikes are geared differently but both are 2x to keep that tighter rear cassette and allow for more gear options as surface, elevation, wind, and strain from the longer rides determine I need changes
agreed. I like having the option of 2x up front, one which I spend most my time in, then an overdrive or sprinting gear.. this gives you the option for a close ratio rear cassette.
3x is also good because it can give you an overall better chainline when used properly.
Whether your bike is 1x , 2x or 3x, the most important is having the correct ratio combinations between front ring(s) and the rear cassette.
My new trek verve e bike has a 38t front with 11-36 cassette rear. 38x36 on a very tough climb wouldn't be so easy with electric and a heavy load, but manageable. This is my first 1x bike and I am enjoying the simplicity of no front derailleur or extra shifter. The teeth profile of a single chainring not designed for shifting is more durable and another plus. I would prefer a smaller jump between the cogs in the rear though.
both my trek hybrid bikes (fx 7.3 and the verve) have a 38 x 11 as my top gear. I wouldn't feel comfortable going any faster and never had an issue with spinning out unless I am going down a very steep hill. 40x11 is a releastic top gear that will keep you safe and offer you a more usable range overall with better spacing for real world riding.
I would prefer a 12 or 13t final gear in my cassette though.
.