Originally Posted by rumstove

I recently bought and installed some PDW Full Metal fenders 700x45. The 700x45 size is for 35 max tire size, which is what my tires are. REI is having a sale on the "city" fenders, which is the older name for the same size, but that older style has chrome stays and I wanted everything black so I ended up ordering from PDW (currently sold out now). Like most fenders they were a pain to install but they seem solid and I really like the look. Being that I just recently put them on I can't comment on durability.
I have another bike that needs fenders. Just for the sake of variety I think I'm going to try Handsome Mud Butlers for that bike.
Here's my Tripper with the PDW fenders.