I have the Cannondale cages on my Quick 1 and they work just fine and add a splash of color to the bike.

Material used will impact weight which matters to some and not to others. I doubt you would notice the difference between any of the materials.

I like SKS stuff and they have some bottle cage options to consider:
https://sks-us.com/collections/bottle-cages

I like the looks of the polycarbon option:
https://sks-us.com/collections/bottl...er-bottle-cage