Originally Posted by bblair

UPDATE: I was in my LBS today (that's another sad story that I will post about later) and he showed me how the rear rim was indeed worn. Almost concave, compared to the front. I do go through rear brake pads more often that front.

After online research, including a lot here on BF, here is where I am now:

Psimet wheels with either Industry Nine or Chris King hubs. CK seem like best of the best, but I9 are a little less costly and I love the look. Also straight pull.
I9 wheels with their rims. But so many products, kind of choice paralysis. My LBS is listed as a dealer, but their website does not list any rim brake options.
Chris King wheels. I know about their hubs, but nothing about their rims, and they only make one.

Not looking for the cheapest, nor the most expensive. Somewhere in the middle.