Originally Posted by
amazinmets73
Can you provide any more scientifically credible tests? Shouldn't be difficult if the topic has indeed been beaten to death.
Originally Posted by
amazinmets73
I didn't ask anyone to disprove the assertions. I merely asked for more studies in regards to the performance of different bike frame materials. Like I said, if the subject had indeed been beaten to death, there should be a lot of information on the subject. I'm interested in the results.
I've quoted the challenge you actually posted. His point was that the experiment was so transparently bad that this was just another steel vs. carbon thread. Why would he need to produce more scientifically credible tests to support that? You've got one of a hell of a non sequitur in there-if there aren't any credible experiments, that doesn't imply that the subject isn't played out.
Sorry, but if you were actually interested in a reasonable discussion, you should have acknowledged the problems with the op and then asked politely if anyone knew of a better approach to studying the i
RChung is on this thread, probably the most patient and knowledgeable person about testing on the forums. I know he's always been generous answering my uninformed questions.