Originally Posted by
yannisg
I installed the RD-8000 together with the 34 tooth sprocket on Ultegra 6800 shifters a year ago.
I must of installed the RD in the correct position because I noticed how short the distance was between the end of the chain stay cable housing entrance to the barrel adjuster.
I had no problems shifting.
Recently, I replaced my old shifters with Ultegra 8000.
I removed the RD to check the hanger alignment which was ok.
When I re-installed the RD I must have inadvertently placed the butting surface on the hanger between the upper and lower RD notches.
In this position, the housing was longer.
I went for a ride did a couple of adjustments to the barrel adjuster, and all was well.
A riding friend with the same bike and RD had the setup as I originally had it.
That puzzled me so I posted the question.
When the reply came I re-installed the RD according to Shimano's dwg with the lower RD notch butting against the surface "z" on the hanger. I had a hard time installing the inflexible cable housing within such a short distance; I need to get some flexible cable housing.
Went for a ride did some minor adjustments and all was well.
Shimano indicated that there should be no gap on surface "z" because the gap could affect shifting.
I don't know how much the RD would rotate if tightened within specs.
Also, what is the upper RD notch for; a possible different setup.
I can't say the shifting was any different between the 2 setups, but maybe in the long run it would be.
I don't know what the upper RD notch (stopper) is for. There is no mention of it in Shimano manuals. The 'Shadow' style MTB RDs that I have seen doesn't have it. Also don't recall seeing any modern RD hangers that would use a stopper in that location.
As for the cable housing, the type mentioned in the other post above is the Shimano recommended one. Seems to be low compression coiled housing, similar construction to brake housing. Originally, in the 1980s, the SIS cables were also wound. This was before the SP40/41, linear strand was used.