Originally Posted by
spelger
does anyone know why there is such a difference in their sizing guide compared to everywhere else i've read?
This attempt at standardizing things with a nominal width is not an exact science. Just looking at pictures of saddles will tell you that they are shaped differently and that the contact points can be further in, further out, further forward, or further back.
As mentioned above, going a little too wide rarely has consequences as compared to the severe penalty for going too narrow.