Originally Posted by
jon c.
Assuming the condition is relatively equal, go with the one that feels like the best fit.
Agreed.
But you've listed two bikes. I assume these are both used bikes? Have you looked at them? My very inexperienced advice says fit is first. After fit (assuming they're fairly equal), select the one that's in the best condition.
Also, how urgently do you want to buy? The market for bikes is predicted to get pretty soft in 2023 so there's potential for picking up a better bike for roughly the same money if you can stand to wait.