UPDATE: I should have mentioned before that what's I have on there now are a mis-matched schwable / bontrager 700 x 35.
I have ordered a pair of Continental GP5000 700x32s. The original tires on the bike were Continental Top Touring Tires that were almost super-human. I rode them until they were threadbare. True this is just one 50 mile ride for me, but I'm enjoying it, so I think it might not be my last, so I figured I'd pay a little more for what seems like a good value.
I truly appreciate all of the great advice, support, and feedback.