What we think won't matter. What you think will. For example. I do not like the Cambium saddles. I prefer their leather ones. Also, perineum pain with a saddle, especially the Brooks, is due to how the bike is set up. generally speaking it results from a too high saddle height, or too much reach. The seat being too far forward can cause it too. Generally though, dropping the saddle height will magically fix the problem, never to return again.