As other suggested, focus on fit first, then consider components and brand. Each brand has their own way of maximizing their value per dollar. Example: Cannondale uses FSA cranks. Trek uses non-Shimano brakes.

Not to be redundant but I will - Look at components and decide what is most important for you.

I'm a fan of Cannondale and think the Quick 1 is a great bike but a stretch for your budget. I lucked into mine when a friend upgraded to a road bike after a year of riding. 105 is an amazing group set but way more than I need. I love the hydruaulic disc brakes. 2x11 is my favorite setup but a good 3x9 option. My wife has a Verve 3 (Alivio) and she spends 99% of the time on the middle front sprocket and adjusts the rear as needed.

If I was looking now, I would consider the following bikes with full intent to ride before purchase:

• Jamis Coda (steel) and Allegro (aluminum) - available at my local bike shop 3 miles from home
• Marin Fairfax (hybrid) and Presidio (urban available with IGH!) - closest deal is 25 miles away
• Trek FX - shop is .5 miles from the house
• Cannondale Quick - shop is 15 miles but staff/service is great
• Specialized Sirrus - two shops within 15 mile radius