Bart78

My thoughts based on my experiences:
1. I agree with some statements from article about SMP saddles: the most important is shape - there is no need for any padding if the shape completely matches cyclist's body. Of course it is impossible to achieve this via mass production of saddles - padding helps a little.
2. Using bibs with chamois is not essential, but in most cases it helps...If You feel discomfort riding without chamois relatively short distance means the saddle is not perfect.
3. In my opinion chamois with gel pads is a misconception... I consider only thin foam chamois. Chamois is not for leveling lack of padding in the saddle.
4. I know exactly what features should have a perfect saddle for me. Aelous, prologo dimension and power arc have best shapes for me. The saddle should also have elastic shell.