Originally Posted by
TejanoTrackie
I disagree with the text that I’ve placed in bold. Head tube angle works in concert with fork offset (rake) to attain a certain amount of trail for different performance characteristics. Racing bikes require quicker steering than touring bikes, while still being stable at high speeds. As to my statement that head tube angle affects the shock absorbing qualities of forks, this is not a “belief”, but rather physical mechanics that can be quantified. The force that the wheel applies to the fork can be broken into two components as follows:
Axial component = Vertical force x SIN (head tube angle)
Transverse (perpendicular) component = Vertical force x COSINE (head tube angle)
As the head tube angle becomes slacker (smaller), the axial component of force becomes lower and the transverse component becomes higher. The axial stiffness of a fork leg is much higher than its flexural (bending) stiffness, such that axial shock force is transmitted with almost no attenuation, whereas transverse force is reduced far more as the fork flexes in bending.
Your calculations are based on the assumption that
significant flexing of the fork does indeed occur. As I said, I'd love to see numbers from measurements.
Proponents of the idea that steel and titanium bike frames absorb road shock far better than aluminum frames make similar assumptions, but
measurements of 1997 model year steel, titanium, and aluminum race bike frames showed that, for the chosen simulated rider weight (not specified, annoyingly), the vertical compliance of a Lightspeed titanium frame was 0.064" (and that of a Serotta Ti frame with "oversize" main tubes measured 0.054") whereas that of a Cannondale aluminum frame was 0.049", a difference of 0.015". Is such a difference perceptible, apart from tire and seatpost compliance (and, of course, confirmation bias)? I think not.
(I originally wrote that straight forks now dominate the market, but then I realized I haven't paid much attention to current designs for years, so I hedged my bet.)