I looked at that Heybike City 2.0 amazon listing. The bare bike was around $598 plus $75 shipping. nut if you wanted a front basket, the price went to $949. With a phone mount, $929/ With mirrors, sold out.
I doubt it's worth bugging the seller for a new fender, as the City 2.0 appears to be a well reviewed Heybike that Heybike no longer sells. It seems to be on clearance at amazon by a third party seller. Luckily, its motor and battery look generic, but a 3rd part warranty might be advisable, except....
Those amazon warranties kind of suck. If you didn't get or save the confirming emails when you bought those effing warranties, they won't honor them.
.