Originally Posted by
Duragrouch
(bold) Respectfully, whoa-whoa-whoa. Bearing balls, when functioning properly, are rolling contact, that's actually how they are categorized as bearings. If they are not rolling but staying stationary and sliding against one or both races, that is known as bearing ball skidding, and it will flat spot the bearing ball in nothing flat, and then function is impeded from thereon. That is part of the recommendations for a slight preload on angular contact bearings, it reduces skidding. This is from online, a bearing company:
If you have a bearing without *rolling* elements, but sliding contact, that is a bushing.
Regarding precession, it's due to a radial force, that rotates direction with respect to the threads. The BB threads are set up for precession to tighten the BB cup or cartridge. If you have a fixed gear bike and they were to ride in reverse with a good amount of pedal force, the BB would back out. If you have a mid-drive bike that transmits motor power mid-spindle, and the rider is not pedaling, or just has weight on the pedals with no turning motion, the BB will not back out, because the radial force on the BB is not rotating orientation, it's all one direction from chain tension or rider weight. But if, on that same BB, the ball bearings actually seize up or stop rotating so that they are sliding on the BB, then the force on the BB cups is opposite intended direction and it will back out if the frictional force is sufficient.
Ball. Bearings. Roll. That's why they are round.
I'll have to look at your time of post, it may have been very late local to you. I've made mental errors in the wee hours.
The bearings aren't static, but there is simply no way that anything round can strictly roll when the spindle race diameter is different than the cup race diameter. Something has to slip, as you can clearly see in the gif I posted.
And really, how can you read about "excessive skidding" without wondering why there would be any skidding? That skidding is what has to happen for the reasons I stated.
Bearing preload makes sense when the bearing is going to support thousands of pounds on the axle, heat up greatly or have large load variations. None of which apply to bikes. You have all the information necessary, but keep coming to the wrong conclusions. And you didn't even understand the bearings you are preloading.
I posted at 10am. Apparently you are equally good with time conversions.