Originally Posted by
veganbikes
So you don't believe in figuring out the problem first? Just replace it and hopefully we get lucky and that solves it? That sounds like what either a lazy or inexperienced mechanic would do. A good mechanic is going to diagnose the problem first and then recommend solutions not go for "solutions" without knowing the problem.
A bike used in a normal way shouldn't need that much alignment if you need that much alignment my guess is your derailleur is out of whack or you have done something wrong or just don't know how to use the hanger alignment tool (which is not uncommon). I know why I would make a claim that a bike used in a normal way shouldn't need a bunch of alignment because it is true. I work in and own a shop so I know that we rarely need to adjust hangers on normally used bikes. I don't know why you keep having these problems but I am guessing there is some issue in your training or you have some customers who are really bad with their bikes or you are selling some really cheap stuff that most shops wouldn't sell because it is so problematic.
What the hell are you reading???? If it is due to "composition, design or fatigue", then I have clearly "figured out the problem". And that hanger will (no longer) hold position under shifting and chain tension loads, as well as normal handling.
Do you really not understand that some hangers are trash?