Originally Posted by
TiHabanero
I don't have a problem with them per se, however it appears that they are simply a roll top dry bag with a mount for a rack on them. Dunno what I was expecting, I guess, as that is pretty much what the pictures depict now that I look at them with scrutiny. I am certain they are quality as their are plenty of positive testimonials out there.
Yup, that is what they are.
I do not know if the mounting hardware has changed much since I bought mine, but I think they are great, a strap that you can use to lift them opens the clamps. You secure the hooks on the rack and the hooks have closures that secure them from below so they do not fall off. They easily adjust for hook position on a rail, use a simple 3mm allen wrench to tighten them in place.
I do not know what rack you are using, I usually use a Tubus Logo EVO, but on my light touring bike instead I use a Racktime Addit rack. I can easily adjust the hooks to fit just right to have exactly the amount of heel clearance I want, no more and no less.. The lower hook also can be easily fit to a good position on the rack.
I use some clear plastic hose from the hardware store, slit lengthwise over the tubing and keep it in place with zip ties and electrical tape to prevent chafing on the rack. I do not use the hook inserts, the 1/2 inch OD / 3/8 inch ID hose fits nicely inside the hooks without the hook inserts.
That said, maybe they have changed the hook design in the past decade and a half.
Photos above, the Logo EVO, the Addit below.
If after the warranty period is up a part of the pannier breaks (unlikely), you can buy spare parts too. I think the part most likely to break is the lower hook.