Originally Posted by
Paul_P
Having read similar comments in the past, I've installed an extra hook on all my panniers from the idea two hooks have less chance of breaking than one, and if one does break, I still have one left.
I've had to move, or flip, the rail piece in which the hooks ride to better fit the racks I've used. Not hard to do.
I've also put some self-stick rubber discs under the hooks for a snug fit and to prevent chattering on the rack.
I find the hooks a bit of a pain to tighten and loosen, but it's only once a day so not the end of the world.
I’ve never broken a lower hook, but I did have one fall off and go missing after riding most of the day on rough roads. And yes, they can rattle sometimes. Installing a cushion is a good idea. I don’t have to loosen them to get the panniers off and on.