Thanks for all the suggestions and whatnot, you were all very helpful.
I did take one ride without wearing a helmet, but that same day, I managed to find an old black BMX (early 90's) Bell helmet in a garage closet.
Finally got to my LBS and tried on a few helmets and went for a Smith Engage Mips.

Screenshot from Smith Optics website
The helmet was on discount by Smith already and the shop also gave me a discount, so I got a great helmet for a even greater price. At least that's what I'm thinking?
Thanks again for all the help with this. I was really lost and going to my LBS was a solid suggestion. Not to mention all the other suggestions.
Hopefully this new helmet will never have to fulfill it's duty.
My life without a bicycle just wouldn't be complete.