Thread: New Old Bike
View Single Post
Old 10-12-25 | 09:35 AM
  #13  
djb
Senior Member
15 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 13,928
Likes: 1,243
From: Montreal Canada
Originally Posted by Trakhak
The reason it disappeared:

When Biopace first appeared (on sport-touring bikes but not racing bikes), reviewers in bike magazines praised it to the skies.

Then Shimano got greedy and added Biopace to their racing bike component groups. Racers disliked the feel in general and when pedaling at high cadences and sprinting in particular and bad-mouthed it. The reviewers then did a 180 and damned it.

In response, Shimano introduced Biopace II, with much-reduced eccentricity (and some further, almost-round version whose name I've forgotten). But the damage was done, and Shimano soon gave up and dropped Biopace.

Ironically, Biopace made/makes perfect sense for the original target market.

The majority of casual and beginner sport cyclists (a.k.a. the majority of cyclists, period) have always tended to pedal a high-ish gear at a low cadence. Someone at Shimano noticed and figured that they could make cycling more enjoyable for those low-cadence cyclists by offering eccentric chainrings.

The idea was that, as a consequence of effectively reducing the gear ratio through the power section of the pedal stroke and increasing the ratio through the dead spots at the top and bottom, the rider's cadence would be higher and the load lower where it counted, with the bonus of more rest time per revolution.

A very few people have reported experiencing problems with Biopace over the years, many more have said that they've been happy with them, and the majority of users have probably been indifferent. Chances are therefore good that the OP will get along fine with them.
I agree with everything you wrote, especially about the vast majority of folks using high ish gear and low cadence. I know a number of people who pedal often like this.
So in theory the oval thing is a nice idea, but my experience was a classic one, as soon as you start to get to higher cadences, its an issue--- VERY much compounded by downtube shifters, where we just dont shift as often as with other types of shifters.
Mine might have been Biopace 2, I got rid of the rings years ago not to be tempted to try them again.

and yes, this fellow might find them fine. Up to him.
djb is offline  
Reply