I don’t think anyone is arguing that paper maps are objectively better than digital solutions.

I’m a sound engineer and work almost exclusively with the latest and greatest digital gear.
However, I do respect others who prefer analogue gear. There’s a different workflow and a different result.

If you get the chance, listen to a vinyl record of Dark Side of the Moon on a high quality hi-fi system. There are elements to the sound which modern recording techniques are unable to reproduce, but which enhance the experience of listening to a recording.

There is a possibility that AI will soon make better music than humans. And I’m sure people will call others ”die-hards” for wanting to listen to humans play music. So be it.

In the same way, I would submit that modern navigation tools have taken away some of the experience of adventure in bicycle touring.

Not knowing every twist and turn and gradient along the way can enhance the experience.