View Single Post
Old 02-24-26 | 08:33 AM
  #16  
Smaug1's Avatar
Smaug1
Commuter, roadie
Titanium Club Membership
Community Builder
Community Influencer
 
Joined: Jun 2022
Posts: 2,844
Likes: 2,353
From: SE Wisconsin, USA

Bikes: Trek: Domane AL3, Checkpoint SL7; Priority Apollo 11, ZiZZO Forte + eBikes

Originally Posted by Jipe
Brompton do not have a "Super Downtube" nor a Deltech cable and nevertheless their frames last forever!

This is pure marketing ****.
Not so fast, with the pitchforks and torches!

Originally Posted by Bleu
It's a G line clone. Except it's aluminum. It isn't lighter, or even specced better. Why not just buy the Brompton ?
Well, price is one possible reason, Bleu.

The fact that Bromptons are aluminum instead of steel is a huge difference. Steel is a lot more ductile than aluminum. It can flex a bit all the time without wearing out, whereas aluminum can only flex so many times and then it breaks. Aluminum is usually made thicker and stiffer, to avoid the flex & breakage, whereas steel bikes are not made to be so stiff, as the flex is a good trait. Especially in the un-braced Brompton design. That flex in the steel tubing is a big part of why they ride so well despite having 16" tires at 100 psi.

As to the weight, I don't know if Brompton uses better components or thinner tubing to keep the weight down, but they do know what they're doing with this design.
__________________
-Jeremy
Smaug1 is offline  
Reply