Originally Posted by Koyote

This photo illustrates the problem with many fenders: they don’t protect the parts that actually benefit from staying clean - like the chain, chainrings, bottom bracket, pedals, etc. This one apparently only protected the down tube, which is easy to clean and unharmed by a little mud.

I’m not anti-fender- I just finished a ride on one of my fendered bikes. But to really be worthwhile, the front fender needs to come down close enough so that, with a flap attached, you have coverage to within just two or 3 inches of the pavement. Otherwise, all the junk that sprays off the front wheel ends up right where you don’t want it. Like in this photo.


.