To me, it seems like they're missing out on the bigger picture here. Some guys(myself included) prefer a lighter bike with 3-4' of travel. I have to pay more attention, and pick my lines a little better, but I prefer the lighter weight and solid rear end for climbing. Other guys prefer the big travel, 'cuz they like taking the big hits. Whatever floats your boat, I guess. Just remember that you actually CAN ride, and what it feels like to do it.