Originally Posted by bbonnn
Can I also ask a stupid question: what's the deal with chrome fenders? Are they mainly just cosmetically appealing if you're into the retro look, or are there practical benefits over the plastic ones? Are they more or less durable, resistant to weather/rust/scratches, etc.? Or just flashy?
A lot of the retro-guys (myself included) prefer chromed steel fenders for strength and aesthetics. They're more durable and they're not much heavier than plastic fenders, especially with a loaded bike. There's a reason why so many of the old Raleigh 3-speeds and Schwinn cruisers still have their steel fenders intact - they last. Plus you have more options for attaching lights or small racks directly to the fender, giving yourself more arrangements like a French constructeur touring bike. For everyday commuters I don't think they are appreciably better than the nice plastics (SKS), but on a high-end bike like a Herse, Singer, or Rivendell custom nothing else would really do.
Edit: To the OP - get the SKS and you'll be happy.